Looking on the internet deeply has found these results:

by giving the students is the most popular phrase on the web. 

Related Comparison

• Thanks for correcting for or Thanks for the correction.?
• creativity at its finest or Creativity to the core ?
• call the clinic or call to the clinic?
• give to the students or giving the students?
• Thanks for the correction. or Thanks for fixing them?
• give the system or give to the system?