Looking on the internet deeply has found these results:

catch my eye is the most popular phrase on the web.

catch my eyes 1336,000 results on the web	catch my eye 1575,000 results on the web More popular!
Some examples and use cases from the internet:	Some examples and use cases from the internet:
It doesn't look like this phrase is very popular! The search could not find any examples on the internet.	My eye should catch your eye, I would like to say that in this case it is going to be very easy for me because everyone who has asked to 'catch my eye' is female. Mr President, it is indeed and I think you failed to catch my eye. As for the question you asked me, I am going to catch my own eye and think about it, to help you in my modest way. Driving around slow, looking to catch an eye. She's been trying to catch my eye ever since I came in. I like to collect things that catch my eye. Yes, it takes a very special kind of woman to catch my eye and ignite my passion.

catch my eyes

1336,000 results on the web

catch my eye

1575,000 results on the web

More popular!

It doesn't look like this phrase is very popular! The search could not find any examples on the internet.

My eye should catch your eye,
I would like to say that in this case it is going to be very easy for me because everyone who has asked to 'catch my eye' is female.
Mr President, it is indeed and I think you failed to catch my eye.
As for the question you asked me, I am going to catch my own eye and think about it, to help you in my modest way.
Driving around slow, looking to catch an eye.
She's been trying to catch my eye ever since I came in.
I like to collect things that catch my eye.
Yes, it takes a very special kind of woman to catch my eye and ignite my passion.