Looking on the internet deeply has found these results:

Defective with is the most popular phrase on the web.

Defective of 182,900 results on the web	Defective with 1147,000 results on the web More popular!
Some examples and use cases from the internet:	Some examples and use cases from the internet:
It doesn't look like this phrase is very popular! The search could not find any examples on the internet.	When tested with a defective component in accordance with Appendix 1 of Annex XI, the OBD system malfunction indicator shall be activated. The fourth ground concerns an error of law and defective reasoning with regard to the lawfulness of the order for recovery in Article 3 of the contested decision. The resulting defective drainage in conjunction with meteorological conditions, has irreversible consequences for the area. I was born with a defective tumor Idursulfase replaces the enzyme that is missing or defective in patients with Hunter syndrome. The EU market is flooded with defective goods that we are purchasing from China. Where the vehicle is found to be defective with regard to the test items below, the competent authorities in the Member States must adopt a procedure for setting the conditions under which the vehicle may be used before passing another roadworthiness test. When tested with a defective component in accordance with Appendix 1 to Annex 11 to this Regulation, the OBD system malfunction indicator shall be activated.

Defective of

182,900 results on the web

Defective with

1147,000 results on the web

More popular!

It doesn't look like this phrase is very popular! The search could not find any examples on the internet.

When tested with a defective component in accordance with Appendix 1 of Annex XI, the OBD system malfunction indicator shall be activated.
The fourth ground concerns an error of law and defective reasoning with regard to the lawfulness of the order for recovery in Article 3 of the contested decision.
The resulting defective drainage in conjunction with meteorological conditions, has irreversible consequences for the area.
I was born with a defective tumor
Idursulfase replaces the enzyme that is missing or defective in patients with Hunter syndrome.
The EU market is flooded with defective goods that we are purchasing from China.
Where the vehicle is found to be defective with regard to the test items below, the competent authorities in the Member States must adopt a procedure for setting the conditions under which the vehicle may be used before passing another roadworthiness test.
When tested with a defective component in accordance with Appendix 1 to Annex 11 to this Regulation, the OBD system malfunction indicator shall be activated.