He told me that she had had an accident VS He told me that she had an accident
He told me that she had had an accident VS He told me that she had an accident – correct phrase or sentence to use.
Looking on the internet deeply has found these results:
He told me that she had an accident is the most popular phrase on the web.
He told me that she had had an accident1900 results on the web |
He told me that she had an accident450,000 results on the web More popular! |
|---|---|
Some examples and use cases from the internet: |
Some examples and use cases from the internet: |
|
|
Correct Usage of Has, Had, Have in the Situation of Accident
The present perfect (“has/have” + past participle) always directs to an action which happened in the past, but carries over to the present.
If I say, “He had an accident,” it occurred in the past and it’s over. Maybe it was few years ago and he’s fine nowadays.
“He has had an accident” means that the accident already happened, but there are still consequences from it right now. Maybe he’s injured and is bleeding. Perhaps his car is wrecked and I need to take him home.
If it is truly in the present, if he is falling down the stairs as I am speaking, I have to say, “He is having an accident.” This is rare, because accidents are usually things that happen fast.
So, if I hear “He has had an accident,” I assume that it happened very recently—within the last few minutes or hours, perhaps.
Want to check your own writing right now?
Paste your text into our 100% free multi-tool workspace.
Upgrade to Grammarchecker.io Premium
Unlock 10 AI rewriting modes, unlimited word paraphrasing, executive fluency feedback, and deep plagiarism checking.