Looking on the internet deeply has found these results:

I made it on the first try is the most popular phrase on the web.

I made it at the first try 13 results on the web	I made it on the first try 1302 results on the web More popular!
Some examples and use cases from the internet:	Some examples and use cases from the internet:
Feb 21, 2013 ... Reply · :iconkurururyu: KururuRyu Featured By Owner Aug 22, 2015 Hobbyist General Artist. I made it at the first try!!! :heart: feels like a nerd Jan 15, 2013 ... ... of experience during that 5 year in the second year i made my instructor course an i made it at the first try, but i continue as a divemaster for a ... Sep 21, 2013 ... I made it at the first try and i did only get 2 star wanted level. If the cagobob go away when you try to shot the pilot just fly away and come back ...	Nov 11, 2014 ... "The first basket was awesome because I was happy I made it on the first try," Hill said. "But I made the second with my right hand. So the ... Nov 2, 2014 ... "The first basket was awesome because I was happy I made it on the first try," Hill says. "But I made the second with my right hand. So the ... Nov 3, 2014 ... Hill said, “It's a dream come true. The first basket was awesome and I was happy that I made it on the first try. My second shot was just as sweet. Nov 2, 2014 ... "The first basket was good, and I was happy I made it on the first try. The second basket was even more awesome because I made it with my ...

I made it at the first try

13 results on the web

I made it on the first try

1302 results on the web

More popular!

Feb 21, 2013 ... Reply · :iconkurururyu: KururuRyu Featured By Owner Aug 22, 2015 Hobbyist General Artist. I made it at the first try!!! :heart: *feels like a nerd*
Jan 15, 2013 ... ... of experience during that 5 year in the second year i made my instructor course an i made it at the first try, but i continue as a divemaster for a ...
Sep 21, 2013 ... I made it at the first try and i did only get 2 star wanted level. If the cagobob go away when you try to shot the pilot just fly away and come back ...

Nov 11, 2014 ... "The first basket was awesome because I was happy I made it on the first try," Hill said. "But I made the second with my right hand. So the ...
Nov 2, 2014 ... "The first basket was awesome because I was happy I made it on the first try," Hill says. "But I made the second with my right hand. So the ...
Nov 3, 2014 ... Hill said, “It's a dream come true. The first basket was awesome and I was happy that I made it on the first try. My second shot was just as sweet.
Nov 2, 2014 ... "The first basket was good, and I was happy I made it on the first try. The second basket was even more awesome because I made it with my ...