Looking on the internet deeply has found these results:

I made it on the first try is the most popular phrase on the web.

I made it at the first try 13 results on the web	I made it on the first try 1302 results on the web More popular!
Some examples and use cases from the internet:	Some examples and use cases from the internet:
Feb 21, 2013 ... Reply � :iconkurururyu: KururuRyu Featured By Owner Aug 22, 2015 Hobbyist General Artist. I made it at the first try!!! :heart: feels like a nerd Jan 15, 2013 ... ... of experience during that 5 year in the second year i made my instructor course an i made it at the first try, but i continue as a divemaster for a�... Sep 21, 2013 ... I made it at the first try and i did only get 2 star wanted level. If the cagobob go away when you try to shot the pilot just fly away and come back�...	Nov 11, 2014 ... "The first basket was awesome because I was happy I made it on the first try," Hill said. "But I made the second with my right hand. So the�... Nov 2, 2014 ... "The first basket was awesome because I was happy I made it on the first try," Hill says. "But I made the second with my right hand. So the�... Nov 3, 2014 ... Hill said, �It's a dream come true. The first basket was awesome and I was happy that I made it on the first try. My second shot was just as sweet. Nov 2, 2014 ... "The first basket was good, and I was happy I made it on the first try. The second basket was even more awesome because I made it with my�...

I made it at the first try

13 results on the web

I made it on the first try

1302 results on the web

More popular!

Feb 21, 2013 ... Reply � :iconkurururyu: KururuRyu Featured By Owner Aug 22, 2015 Hobbyist General Artist. I made it at the first try!!! :heart: *feels like a nerd*
Jan 15, 2013 ... ... of experience during that 5 year in the second year i made my instructor course an i made it at the first try, but i continue as a divemaster for a�...
Sep 21, 2013 ... I made it at the first try and i did only get 2 star wanted level. If the cagobob go away when you try to shot the pilot just fly away and come back�...

Nov 11, 2014 ... "The first basket was awesome because I was happy I made it on the first try," Hill said. "But I made the second with my right hand. So the�...
Nov 2, 2014 ... "The first basket was awesome because I was happy I made it on the first try," Hill says. "But I made the second with my right hand. So the�...
Nov 3, 2014 ... Hill said, �It's a dream come true. The first basket was awesome and I was happy that I made it on the first try. My second shot was just as sweet.
Nov 2, 2014 ... "The first basket was good, and I was happy I made it on the first try. The second basket was even more awesome because I made it with my�...