Looking on the internet deeply has found these results:

i play in the evening is the most popular phrase on the web.

i play at evening 18 results on the web	i play in the evening 13,090,000 results on the web More popular!
Some examples and use cases from the internet:	Some examples and use cases from the internet:
We were going to arrive in London and play the same evening. A record of the delightful piece they're going to play this evening. I must play this evening, that passes above all. Your play this evening, it was remarkable, wasn't it? On our wedding day, your Pa left to play cards all evening. Could you find Mr Barrie and remind him that they're doing his play this evening. Around 1860, she took numerous minor parts in plays, and some evenings, lovers to her bed. Your father tells me you wrote this evening's play yourself.	Around 1860, she took numerous minor parts in plays, and some evenings, lovers to her bed. Your father tells me you wrote this evening's play yourself. Your play this evening, it was remarkable, wasn't it? Could you find Mr Barrie and remind him that they're doing his play this evening. We were going to arrive in London and play the same evening. On our wedding day, your Pa left to play cards all evening. I must play this evening, that passes above all. A record of the delightful piece they're going to play this evening.

i play at evening

18 results on the web

i play in the evening

13,090,000 results on the web

More popular!

We were going to arrive in London and play the same evening.
A record of the delightful piece they're going to play this evening.
I must play this evening, that passes above all.
Your play this evening, it was remarkable, wasn't it?
On our wedding day, your Pa left to play cards all evening.
Could you find Mr Barrie and remind him that they're doing his play this evening.
Around 1860, she took numerous minor parts in plays, and some evenings, lovers to her bed.
Your father tells me you wrote this evening's play yourself.

Around 1860, she took numerous minor parts in plays, and some evenings, lovers to her bed.
Your father tells me you wrote this evening's play yourself.
Your play this evening, it was remarkable, wasn't it?
Could you find Mr Barrie and remind him that they're doing his play this evening.
We were going to arrive in London and play the same evening.
On our wedding day, your Pa left to play cards all evening.
I must play this evening, that passes above all.
A record of the delightful piece they're going to play this evening.