Looking on the internet deeply has found these results:

In that circumstance is the most popular phrase on the web.

Under that circumstance 182,900 results on the web	In that circumstance 1388,000 results on the web More popular!
Some examples and use cases from the internet:	Some examples and use cases from the internet:
It doesn't look like this phrase is very popular! The search could not find any examples on the internet.	In that circumstance, reestablishing control of the ship should be our top priority. The use of oil in that circumstance is, as I understand it, illegal, a breach of the food and hygiene regulations. It's just a question of what puts us in that situation where the circumstances outweigh the consequences. A Caucasian can only do that in exceptional circumstances. Following the allegation made in the complaint that circumstances had changed since the original investigation, the level of dumping for the IP was examined. The Commission failed to take account of that circumstance in the contested decision, as it had promised to do during the procedure. Well, in that circumstance I think he was more listening to Bruce than myself. (14) Following the allegation made in the complaint that circumstances had changed since the original investigation, the level of dumping for the IP was examined.

Under that circumstance

182,900 results on the web

In that circumstance

1388,000 results on the web

More popular!

It doesn't look like this phrase is very popular! The search could not find any examples on the internet.

In that circumstance, reestablishing control of the ship should be our top priority.
The use of oil in that circumstance is, as I understand it, illegal, a breach of the food and hygiene regulations.
It's just a question of what puts us in that situation where the circumstances outweigh the consequences.
A Caucasian can only do that in exceptional circumstances.
Following the allegation made in the complaint that circumstances had changed since the original investigation, the level of dumping for the IP was examined.
The Commission failed to take account of that circumstance in the contested decision, as it had promised to do during the procedure.
Well, in that circumstance I think he was more listening to Bruce than myself.
(14) Following the allegation made in the complaint that circumstances had changed since the original investigation, the level of dumping for the IP was examined.