Looking on the internet deeply has found these results:

our feelings aren't mutual is the most popular phrase on the web.

the feelings are mutual 162,800 results on the web	our feelings aren't mutual 1473,000 results on the web More popular!
Some examples and use cases from the internet:	Some examples and use cases from the internet:
The feeling is mutual, Counsellor. The feeling is mutual, mostly. Well, the feeling's mutual. The feelings are mutual. Say, although the feelings are mutual, we considered the influence it'll have on the international politics, so we decided to break up. I wish the feeling were mutual. The feeling's mutual, cupcake. The feelings are mutual.	But the feeling wasn't mutual. Ray Brauer, but the feelings just weren't mutual. Our mutual feelings are just a bit too drastic. Whatever I may have thought there was between me and Skye, she made it pretty clear the feeling wasn't mutual. The feeling is mutual, mostly. I wish the feeling were mutual. Say, although the feelings are mutual, we considered the influence it'll have on the international politics, so we decided to break up. But the minute I shook his hand, I knew the feeling wasn't mutual.

the feelings are mutual

162,800 results on the web

our feelings aren't mutual

1473,000 results on the web

More popular!

The feeling is mutual, Counsellor.
The feeling is mutual, mostly.
Well, the feeling's mutual.
The feelings are mutual.
Say, although the feelings are mutual, we considered the influence it'll have on the international politics, so we decided to break up.
I wish the feeling were mutual.
The feeling's mutual, cupcake.
The feelings are mutual.

But the feeling wasn't mutual.
Ray Brauer, but the feelings just weren't mutual.
Our mutual feelings are just a bit too drastic.
Whatever I may have thought there was between me and Skye, she made it pretty clear the feeling wasn't mutual.
The feeling is mutual, mostly.
I wish the feeling were mutual.
Say, although the feelings are mutual, we considered the influence it'll have on the international politics, so we decided to break up.
But the minute I shook his hand, I knew the feeling wasn't mutual.