Looking on the internet deeply has found these results:

unexpected but not surprised is the most popular phrase on the web.

unexpected but not surprise 17 results on the web	unexpected but not surprised 112,500 results on the web More popular!
Some examples and use cases from the internet:	Some examples and use cases from the internet:
What a pleasant, but totally unexpected surprise. Mr President, it is an unexpected but welcome honour to be able to speak to you here this evening. What a totally unexpected but welcome surprise! I'd say this visit is unexpected but I despise understatement. I mean, unexpected but it's... An unexpected but small negative correlation between well being and exposure to UMTS exposure was found. Complications would not surprise Dr. Pryce.	I am grateful but not surprised by the tone of the report. I'm disappointed but not surprised, sir. I'm pleased but not surprised. I'm disappointed but not surprised. I am sorry, also like others, that group support is excluded, but not surprised, frankly, in the current febrile circumstances. I'm sorry, but not surprised. Sorry but not surprised, right? I am honored, but not surprised.

unexpected but not surprise

17 results on the web

unexpected but not surprised

112,500 results on the web

More popular!

What a pleasant, but totally unexpected surprise.
Mr President, it is an unexpected but welcome honour to be able to speak to you here this evening.
What a totally unexpected but welcome surprise!
I'd say this visit is unexpected but I despise understatement.
I mean, unexpected but it's...
An unexpected but small negative correlation between well
being and exposure to UMTS exposure was found.
Complications would not surprise Dr. Pryce.

I am grateful but not surprised by the tone of the report.
I'm disappointed but not surprised, sir.
I'm pleased but not surprised.
I'm disappointed but not surprised.
I am sorry, also like others, that group support is excluded, but not surprised, frankly, in the current febrile circumstances.
I'm sorry, but not surprised.
Sorry but not surprised, right?
I am honored, but not surprised.